- Код статьи
- S086960630010955-9-
- DOI
- 10.31857/S086960630010955-9
- Тип публикации
- Статья
- Статус публикации
- Опубликовано
- Авторы
- Том/ Выпуск
- Том / Номер 3
- Страницы
- 125-137
- Аннотация
С ростом популярности «исторической политики» археологические материалы и историческое наследие все чаще превращаются в важный политический ресурс. Сегодня интерес к этому питает не только государство, но и разнообразные общественные и религиозные группы, политические движения, коренные народы и этнические меньшинства, коммерческие предприятия. В таких условиях неожиданно для себя археология вторгается в сферу политики, и ей приходится иметь дело с острыми вопросами, требующими обсуждения важных этических проблем. В данной статье такие проблемы рассматриваются в связи с взаимоотношениями археологов с коренными народами, с подходами к региональному прошлому, с деятельностью коммерческих структур, прежде всего в сфере туризма, с лавиной паранаучных построений, с реакцией на массовую миграцию, а также с острыми этническими конфликтами. Обсуждаются подходы к решению таких острых проблем.
- Ключевые слова
- археология, историческое наследие, этика, коренные народы, паранаука
- Дата публикации
- 29.09.2020
- Год выхода
- 2020
- Всего подписок
- 14
- Всего просмотров
- 618
Библиография
- 1. Abu El-Haj N., 1998. Translating truths: Nationalism, the practice of archaeology, and the remaking of past and present in contemporary Jerusalem. American Ethnologist, vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 166–188.
- 2. Almansa Sánchez J., 2015. Trading Archaeology Is Not Just a Matter of Antiquities: Ar-chaeological Practice as a Commodity. Ethics and archaeological praxis. C. Gnecco, D. Lipper, eds. New York: Springer, pp. 148–153.
- 3. Archaeological fantasies. How pseudoarchaeology misrepresents the past and misleads the public. G.C. Fagan, ed. London: Routledge, 2006. 440 p.
- 4. Belyayev L.A., 2017. V.A. Korenyako and ethical issues in archaeology: to the publication of the “Draft Code of the Russian Archaeologist.” «I muzoyu emu byla nauka»: sbornik pamyati V.A. Korenyako (1952–2016) [“And science was his muse”: Collected papers in memory of V.A. Korenyako (1952–2016)]. S.V. Kuz’minykh, A.A. Gorbenko, eds., comp. Azov: AIAiPMZ, pp. 87–89. (In Russ.)
- 5. Bendremer J.C., Richman K.A., 2006. Human subjects review and archaeology: a view from Indian country. The ethics of archaeology: philosophical perspectives on archaeo-logical practice. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 97–114.
- 6. a. Cole J.R., 1980. Cult archaeology and unscientific method and theory. Advances in archaeological method and theory, 3. M. Schiffer, ed. New York: Academic Press, pp. 1–33.
- 7. Colwell Ch., 2017. Plundered skulls and stolen spirits: inside the fight to reclaim native America's culture. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. 360 p.
- 8. Colwell-Chanthaphonh Ch., Ferguson T.J., 2006. Trust and archaeological practice: to-wards a framework of Virtue Ethics. The ethics of archaeology: philosophical perspec-tives on archaeological practice. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 115–130.
- 9. Cooper D.E., 2006. Truthfulness and ‘inclusion’ in archaeology. The ethics of archaeolo-gy: philosophical perspectives on archaeological practice. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 131–145.
- 10. Cult archaeology and creationism: understanding pseudo-scientific beliefs about the past. F.B. Harrold, R.A. Eve, eds. Iowa City: Univ. of Iowa Press, 1987. 163 p.
- 11. Curtoni R.P., 2015. Against Global Archaeological Ethics: Critical Views from South America. Ethics and archaeological praxis. N.Y.: Springer, pp. 41–47.
- 12. Di Giovine M.A., 2015. Patrimonial Ethics and the Field of Heritage Production. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 201–227.
- 13. Ethics and archaeological praxis. C. Gnecco, D. Lippert, eds. New York: Springer, 2015. 258 p.
- 14. Etika v arkheologii [Ethics in archaeology]. G.T. Obydennova, ed. Ufa: BGPU, 2016. 203 p.
- 15. Falkenhausen L. von, 1995. The regionalist paradigm in Chinese archaeology. National-ism, Politics, and the Practice of Archaeology. P. Kohl, C. Fawcett, eds. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 198–217.
- 16. Feder K.L., 1984. Irrationality and popular archaeology. American Antiquity, vol. 49, no. 3, pp. 525–541.
- 17. Ferguson T.J., 1996. Native Americans and the practice of archaeology. Annual Review of Anthropology, 25, pp. 63–79.
- 18. Fernández V.M., 2015. Europe: Beyond the Canon. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 61–68.
- 19. Formozov A.A., 1977. On criticizing sources in archaeology. SA [Soviet archaeology], 1, pp. 5–14. (In Russ.)
- 20. Formozov A.A., 2005. Chelovek i nauka. Iz zapisey arkheologa [Man and science. From the notes of an archaeologist]. Moscow: Znak. 224 p.
- 21. Fowler P., 1992. The Past in Contemporary Society: Then, Now. London: Routledge. 210 p.
- 22. Giblin J., 2015. Archaeological Ethics and Violence in Post-genocide Rwanda. Ethics and the Archaeology of Violence. A. González-Ruibal, G. Moshenska, eds. New York: Springer, pp. 33–50.
- 23. Gnecco C., 2015. An entanglement of sorts: archaeology, ethics, praxis, multiculturalism. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 1–17.
- 24. Godwin J., 1993. Arktos. The Polar myth in scientific symbolism, and Nazi survival. London: Thames and Hudson. 272 p.
- 25. Greenberg R., 2015. Ethics in Action: A Viewpoint from Israel/Palestine. Ethics and the Archaeology of Violence. New York: Springer, pp. 19–32.
- 26. Haber A., 2015. Archaeology and Capitalist Development: Lines of Complicity. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 95–113.
- 27. Hamilakis Y., 2007a. From ethics to politics. Archaeology and Capitalism: From Ethics to Politics. Y. Hamilakis, P. Duke, eds. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press, pp. 15–40.
- 28. Hamilakis Y., 2007b. The Nation and its Ruins: Antiquity, Archaeology, and National Imagination in Greece. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press. 352 p.
- 29. Hamilakis Y., 2016. Some Debts Can Never Be Repaid: The Archaeo-politics of the Cri-sis. Journal of Modern Greek Studies, vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 228–233.
- 30. Hamilakis Y., 2017. An oneiric archaeology of the crisis: the Amphipolis saga. Archaeolo-gy of the Future/Archäologie der Zukunft (Culturescapes Griechenland). K. Botanova, C.Ch. Cryssopoulos, eds. Basel: Christoph Merian, pp. 16–36.
- 31. Hodder I., 2011. Is a Shared Past Possible? The Ethics and Practice of Archaeology in the Twenty-First Century. New Perspectives in Global Public Archaeology. K. Okamura, A. Matsuda, eds. New York: Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, pp. 19–28.
- 32. Holtorf C., 2005. From Stonehenge to Las Vegas. Archaeology as popular culture. Walnut Creek: AltaMira Press. 198 p.
- 33. Holtorf C., 2006. Can less be more? Heritage in the age of terrorism. Public archaeology, 5, pp. 101–109.
- 34. Holtorf C., 2009. A European perspective on indigenous and immigrant archaeologies. World Archaeology, vol. 41, no. 4, pp. 672–681.
- 35. Jordan P., 2001. The Atlantis Syndrom. Gloucestershire: Sutton Publishing Limited. 309 p.
- 36. Khaydarov Sh., Odegov V., 2006. Sledy ariyskoy tsivilizatsii v Prikam’ye (istoriko-sravnitel’noye izucheniye problemy) [Traces of Aryan civilization in the Kama region (his-torical and comparative study of the issue)]. Perm’: PONITsAA. 96 p.
- 37. Korenyako V.A., 2004. Ethical issues and crisis phenomena in archaeology. Problemy pervobytnoy arkheologii Evrazii (k 75-letiyu A.A. Formozova) [Problems of the prehistoric archaeology of Eurasia (to the 75th anniversary of A.A. Formozov)]. V.I. Gulyayev, S.V. Kuz’minykh, eds., comp. Moscow: IA RAN, pp. 36–47. (In Russ.)
- 38. Korenyako V.A., 2013. The legislation in the protection of archaeological heritage (foreign experience). RA [Russian archaeology], 4, pp. 125–142. (In Russ.)
- 39. Korenyako V.A., 2016a. Professional archaeologists about the ethical issues in their field of studies. Etika v arkheologii [Ethics in archaeology]. Ufa: BGPU, pp. 59–79. (In Russ.)
- 40. Korenyako V.A., 2016b. Ethical issues and crisis manifestations in modern archaeology (six years later. Etika v arkheologii [Ethics in archaeology]. Ufa: BGPU, pp. 179–200. (In Russ.)
- 41. Korenyako V.A., 2017. Code of ethics of the Russian archaeologist. Draft. «I muzoyu emu byla nauka»: sbornik pamyati V.A. Korenyako (1952–2016) [“And science was his muse”: Collected papers in memory of V.A. Korenyako (1952–2016)]. Azov: AIAiPMZ, pp. 89–91. (In Russ.)
- 42. Kupriyanova E.V., 2014. The settlement of Arkaim and the popularization of archaeology in the Southern Urals (to the interaction of science and mass consciousness). Etnografich-eskoye obozreniye [Etnograficheskoe obozrenie (Ethnographic review)], 5, pp. 146–161. (In Russ.)
- 43. Lackey D.P., 2006. Ethics and Native American reburials: a philosopher’s view of two decades of NAGPRA. The ethics of archaeology: philosophical perspectives on archaeo-logical practice. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 146–162.
- 44. Leaman O., 2006. Who guards the guardians? The ethics of archaeology: philosophical perspectives on archaeological practice. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 32–45.
- 45. Marciniak A., 2015. Archaeology and Ethics: The Case of Central-Eastern Europe. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 49–60.
- 46. Matsuda A., Okamura K., 2011. Introduction: New Perspectives in Global Public Ar-chaeology. New Perspectives in Global Public Archaeology. N.Y.: Springer Sci-ence+Business Media, LLC, pp. 1–18.
- 47. McDavid C., 2002. Archaeologies that hurt; descendants that matter: A pragmatic ap-proach to collaboration in the public interpretation of African-American archaeology. World Archaeology, vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 303–314.
- 48. McDavid C., Brock T.P., 2015. The Differing Forms of Public Archaeology: Where We Have Been, Where We Are Now, and Thoughts for the Future. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 159–184.
- 49. McKusick M., 1984. Psychic archaeology from Atlantis to Oz. Archaeology, vol. 37, no. 5, pp. 48–52.
- 50. Meskell L., 2005. Archaeological ethnography: Conversations around Kruger National Park. Archaeologies, vol.1, no. 1, pp. 81–100.
- 51. Michlovic M.G., 1990. Folk archaeology in anthropological perspective. Current anthro-pology, vol. 31, no. 1, pp. 103–107.
- 52. Murray T., 2011. Archaeologists and Indigenous people: A maturing relationship? Annual Review of Anthropology, 40, pp. 363–378.
- 53. Nicholas G., Hollowel J., 2007. Ethical Challenges to a Postcolonial Archaeology: the Legacy of Scientific Colonialism. Archaeology and Capitalism: From Ethics to Politics. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press. Р. 59–82.
- 54. Niklasson E., Hølleland H., 2018. The Scandinavian far-right and the new politicisation of heritage. Journal of Social Archaeology, vol. 18, iss. 2, pp. 121–148.
- 55. Petrov A.E., Belyayev L.A., Buzhilova A.P., 2011. Between science and the regional au-thorities: an experience of falsifying the remains of Ivan Susanin through a targeted inter-pretation of archaeological studies and forensic investigation. Fal’sifikatsiya istoricheskikh istochnikov i konstruirovaniye etnokraticheskikh mifov [Falsification of historical sources and building ethnocratic myths]. A.E. Petrov, V.A. Shnirel’man, eds. Moscow: IA RAN, pp. 247–267. (In Russ.)
- 56. Phillips C., Ross A., 2015. Both Sides of the Ditch: The Ethics of Narrating the Past in the Present. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 27–40.
- 57. Pletts G., Soyenov V.I., Konstantinov N.A., Robinson E., 2014. International significance of the repatriation of “Ukok Princess” (Is Russian archaeology ready for dialogue with indigenous peoples?). Drevnosti Sibiri i Tsentral’noy Azii [Antiquities of Siberia and Cen-tral Asia]. Gorno-Altaysk, 7, pp. 17–45. (In Russ.)
- 58. Pruitt T., 2012. Pyramids, performance and pseudoscience in Visoko, Bosnia. AP: Online Journal in Public Archaeology, 2, pp. 26–34.
- 59. Scham P., Pogrund B., Ghanem A., 2013. Introduction to Shared Narratives – A Palestin-ian-Israeli Dialogue. Israel Studies, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 1–10.
- 60. Scham S., 2009. Diplomacy and desired pasts. Journal of Social Archaeology, vol. 9, iss. 2, pp. 163–199.
- 61. Scham S.A., Yahya A., 2003. Heritage and reconciliation. Journal of Social Archaeology, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 399–416.
- 62. Shepherd N., 2015. Undisciplining Archaeological Ethics. After Ethics: Ancestral Voices and Post-Disciplinary Worlds in Archaeology. A. Haber, N. Shepherd, eds. New York: Springer New York, pp. 10–25.
- 63. Shnirel’man V.A., 2001. The passion of Arkaim: Aryan idea and nationalism. Yazyk i et-nicheskiy konflikt [Language and ethnic conflict]. M.B. Olkott, I. Semenov, eds. Moscow: Gendal’f, pp. 58–85. (In Russ.)
- 64. Shnirel’man V.A., 2002. Identity and images of ancestors: Tatars facing a choice. Vestnik Evrazii [Acta Eurasica], 4, pp. 128–147. (In Russ.)
- 65. Shnirel’man V.A., 2003. Voyny pamyati: mify, identichnost’ i politika v Zakavkaz’ye [Memory wars: myths, identity and politics in Transcaucasia]. Moscow: IKTs Akade-mkniga. 592 p.
- 66. Shnirel’man V.A., 2004. The charm of hoary antiquity: myths of origin in modern text-books. Neprikosnovennyy zapas [Neprikosnovenny zapas (Compulsory stock)], 37, pp. 79–87. (In Russ.)
- 67. Shnirel’man V.A., 2006. Byt’ alanami. Intellektualy i politika na Severnom Kavkaze v XX veke [Being Alans. Intellectuals and politics in the North Caucasus in the 20th century]. Moscow: NLO. 690 p.
- 68. Shnirel’man V.A., 2009. Identity and the policy of post-Soviet memory. Politicheskaya kontseptologiya [Political conceptology], 2, pp. 209–230. (In Russ.)
- 69. Shnirel’man V.A., 2012a. Religion, nationalism and inter-religious conflict in India. Et-nichnost’ i religiya v sovremennykh konfliktakh [Ethnicity and religion in modern con-flicts]. V.A. Tishkov, V. A. Shnirel’man, eds. Moscow: Nauka, pp. 57–109. (In Russ.)
- 70. Shnirel’man V.A., 2012b. Khazarskiy mif: ideologiya politicheskogo radikalizma v Rossii i eye istoki [The Khazarian myth: Ideology of political radicalism in Russia and its ori-gins]. Moscow: Mosty kul’tury: Gesharim. 312 p.
- 71. Shnirel’man V.A., 2013. Science and pseudoscience. Antropologicheskiy forum [Forum for anthropology and culture], 18, pp. 119–128. (In Russ.)
- 72. Shnirel’man V.A., 2015a. Constructing historical heritage – the case of Arkaim. Sibirskiye istoricheskiye issledovaniya [Siberian historical research], 2, pp. 53–65. (In Russ.)
- 73. Shnirel’man V.A., 2015b. Ariyskiy mif v sovremennom mire [Aryan myth in the modern world], 1–2. Moscow: NLO. 2 vols. (536, 440 p.)
- 74. Shnirel’man V.A., 2017. “Aryans”, treasure hunting and society – challenges of postmod-ernism. «I muzoyu emu byla nauka»: sbornik pamyati V.A. Korenyako (1952–2016) [“And science was his muse”: Collected papers in memory of V.A. Korenyako (1952–2016)]. Azov: AIAiPMZ, pp. 92–103. (In Russ.)
- 75. Shnirel’man V.A., 2018. Migrants, xenophobia and social memory – the cases of Austria. Novoye proshloye [The new past], 2, pp. 64–84. (In Russ.)
- 76. Shnirel’man V.A., 2020. Archaeology, historical heritage, and ethical issues. Sibirskiye is-toricheskiye issledovaniya [Siberian historical research], 1, pp. 97–122. (In Russ.)
- 77. Shnirelman V.A., 1996. Who gets the past? Competition for ancestors among non-Russian intellectuals in Russia. Washington; Baltimore; London: Woodrow Wilson Center Press and Johns Hopkins Univ. Press. 98 p.
- 78. Shnirelman V.A., 2018. The politics of the past in Dagestan: national unity and symbolic revolt. Europe-Asia Studies, vol. 70, no. 6, pp. 966–990.
- 79. Smith L., 2004. Archaeological theory and the politics of culture heritage. New York: Routledge. 276 p.
- 80. Snow D., 1981. Martians and Vikings, Madoc and runes. American Heritage, vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 102–108.
- 81. Spriggs M., 1999. Pacific archaeologies: contested ground in the construction of Pacific history. The Journal of Pacific History, vol. 34. no. 1, pp. 109–121.
- 82. The dead and their possessions. Repatriation in principle, policy and practice. C. Fforde, J. Hubert, P. Turnbull, eds. London: Routledge, 2002. 360 p.
- 83. The ethics of archaeology: philosophical perspectives on archaeological practice. Ch. Scarre, G. Scarre, eds. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 2006. 318 p.
- 84. The Future of the Past: Archaeologists, Native Americans, and Repatriation. T.L. Bray, ed. New York: Garland Publishing, 2001. 267 p.
- 85. Thomas S., 2015. Collaborate, Condemn, or Ignore? Responding to Non-Archaeological Approaches to Archaeological Heritage. European Journal of Archaeology, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 312–335.
- 86. Watkins J., 2005. Through wary eyes: Indigenous perspectives on archaeology. Annual Review of Anthropology, 34, pp. 429–449.
- 87. Watkins J., 2015. An Indigenous Anthropologist’s Perspective on Archaeological Ethics. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 23–25.
- 88. Williams S., 1991. Fantastic archaeology. The wild side of North American prehistory. Philadelphia: Univ. of Pennsylvania Press. 424 p.
- 89. Wynn L.L., 2008. Shape Shifting Lizard People, Israelite Slaves, and Other Theories of Pyramid Building: Notes on Labor, Nationalism, and Archaeology in Egypt. Journal of Social Archaeology, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 272–295.
- 90. Yahya A., 2010. The Palestinian-Israeli draft agreement on archaeological heritage. Pre-sent Pasts, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 72–74.
- 91. Yellowhorn E., 2015. Just Methods, No Madness: Historical Archaeology on the Piikani First Nation. Ethics and archaeological praxis. New York: Springer, pp. 245–256.
- 92. Young J.O., 2006. Cultures and the ownership of archaeological finds. The ethics of ar-chaeology: philosophical perspectives on archaeological practice. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 15–31.
- 93. Zimmerman L.J., 2001. Usurping Native American voice. The Future of the Past: Ar-chaeologists, Native Americans, and Repatriation. T. Bray, ed. New York: Garland Pub-lishing, pp. 169–184.